I was really disappointed in this book. Mage had been, for the longest time, one of my favorite games in the World of Darkness. It's like they forgot the definition of the word "Ascension." The best scenario out of all of these features the 'bad guys' winning the Ascension War - its the only one that at least seems consistent with the earlier themes of the game. One of the other stories is best summed up as "Rocks Fall, Everyone Dies." The information about making your own version of Ascension was the most useful part, but considering how much better the first two Judgement books were, this was a severe disappointment. It would have been good to have an ending that wasn't entirely doom and gloom.
[1 of 5 Stars!]